I tried potato salad from Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and Wegmans. One stood out as the clear winner.

Ted Burg
- I tried potato salad from Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and Wegmans.
- The Wegmans option was the most expensive and seemed a bit soupier than the others.
- I enjoyed the Whole Foods Red Bliss potato salad, which had a delicious mustard flavor.
No summertime barbecue or picnic is complete without a few good side dishes, and a scoop of potato salad makes a great addition to a juicy cheeseburger, a plate of smoky ribs, or a hearty deli sandwich.
To me, a good potato salad has a satisfying mix of textures, and enough flavor to liven up the potatoes without overpowering them.
With barbecue season upon us, I decided to try the house-brand potato salads from Wegmans, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods to see how they compare. Here's how I ranked them, from worst to first.
Prices may vary by location.
Wegmans potato salad was the most expensive

Ted Berg
A pound of Wegmans potato salad cost me $5.50, which was the most I paid at any of the stores.
This potato salad looked a bit soupier than the others I tried, with chunks of potato, celery, and pepper flakes floating in the mayo-heavy base.
The potatoes themselves turned out to be the mealiest of any I tried, but there was a nice bit of crunch to the celery and a bit of peppery spice that I liked. There was also an unexpected earthiness from the onions, and they tasted as if they'd been sautΓ©ed.
This potato salad wasn't bad, but it was my least favorite of the three I tried. In my opinion, it was a little heavy for a poolside barbecue side dish. Since it was also the most expensive, it was an easy choice for third place.
I would buy Trader Joe's potato salad again

Ted Berg
Trader Joe's potato salad cost a little less than Wegmans, at $5 a pound. Of the three salads I tried, it was the most consistent in appearance.
It honestly looked and tasted more like egg salad to me, but the yolk-heavy creaminess was enjoyable, and I liked the nice hint of vinegary tang.
This was the sweetest of the three potato salads I tried, which isn't necessarily a selling point for me. I also thought it had the least texture. The potatoes were mushy, and the small bits of celery offered little to no crunch.
I didn't love it, but it was good enough that I'd buy it again if I were at Trader Joe's and needed potato salad.
The Whole Foods Red Bliss potato salad was the clear winner

Ted Berg
Of the three stores I visited, Whole Foods was the only one that packed my potato salad fresh to order at the deli counter.
I can't say for sure if that makes a difference, but the Red Bliss potato salad was undoubtedly the most visually appealing of the three I tried. Red potato skins and green chives added plenty of color to the visibly creamy salad.
Although it typically costs $6, it was marked down to $4.50 per pound the day that I went. So, Whole Foods' potato salad was the least expensive of the three, and from the first bite, the clear winner in quality.
The potatoes had a nice, hearty texture, the celery was crunchy, and the salad packed a strong, delicious mustard flavor.
Since Whole Foods' entry was the least expensive, the best-looking, and the tastiest, its top ranking was a no-brainer. From now on, when the shopping list calls for potato salad, I'll steer toward Whole Foods.